THE Fid Guru BLOG

Insights From Encore Fiduciary on Fiduciary Liability & Other Risk Exposures of Employee Benefit Plans

THE Fid Guru BLOG

Insights From Encore Fiduciary on Fiduciary Liability & Other Risk Exposures of Employee Benefit Plans

Trader Joe’s ERISA Trial: Split Ruling Creates Uncertainty for Plan Sponsors

reviewing legal documents in a law office two hands pointing to a section, gavel in the background
LinkedIn
Twitter
Facebook
Email

By Justin Bove, Encore Fiduciary
and Kent Mason and Adam McMahon, Davis & Harman LLP

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • ERISA Is a Law of Process, Not Outcomes, and Passive Fiduciary Oversight is Not Enough: Trader Joe’s prevailed on the forfeiture and investment performance claims, but lost on recordkeeping fees despite reducing those fees by approximately 20%. The ruling highlights the importance of documenting and following a prudent fiduciary process, even when the results appear reasonable.
  • Are Formal RFPs Now Required? The court’s ruling suggests that benchmarking and informal market inquiries can be insufficient to establish a prudent recordkeeping oversight process. However, ERISA does not expressly require formal RFPs or RFIs, raising questions about whether courts may impose formulaic fiduciary standard.
  • Going to Trial Can Challenge the Economics of ERISA Settlements: Plaintiffs initially sought more than $130 million in damages but received approximately $1.2 million, including prejudgment interest. The significant difference illustrates why plan sponsors and fiduciary insurers should carefully evaluate the costs and risks of settlement versus trial, particularly when plaintiffs rely on questionable damages benchmarks.
  • The Court’s Split Ruling Creates Uncertainty for Plan Sponsors: Both sides have already filed motions with the district court seeking the other party to pay their legal fees, and both parties have appealed the split ruling to the First Circuit.

A federal court ordered Trader Joe’s to pay approximately $1.2 million after a split ERISA trial ruling, a fraction of the $130 million plaintiffs initially sought. The court ruled both for and against the retail grocer in an ERISA class action lawsuit that went to trial. Plaintiff firms routinely use the legal expense of discovery and the uncertainty of trial to leverage settlements in these suits, so this case represents a rare opportunity to see what happens when the court examines the facts, hears testimony from expert witnesses, and calculates damages for participants.

This article examines the impact of the court’s ruling in this case and what it means for plan sponsors who often choose to settle these lawsuits rather than see them through trial.

What Was at Stake in the Trader Joe’s ERISA Trial?

In May 2026, the United States District Court for the District of Massachusetts held a six-day bench trial in the case of Stephan v. Trader Joe’s Company1 to determine whether Trader Joe’s violated ERISA in managing its 401(k) plan. During the relevant class period, the plan had roughly 40,000–45,000 participants and between $2–3 billion in assets.

During the trial, the court considered three central claims raised by the plaintiffs:

  1. whether Trader Joe’s breached its fiduciary duties by allocating forfeitures to reduce future employer contributions instead of using them to pay administrative expenses;
  2. whether it breached its fiduciary duties by retaining an allegedly underperforming growth fund; and
  3. whether it breached its fiduciary duties when overseeing the plan’s recordkeeping fees.


The plaintiffs sought more than $130 million in combined damages – $42 million from the forfeiture claim, $82 million from the investment underperformance claim, and $9 million from the recordkeeping fee claim.

How Did the Court Rule?

The court ruled for Trader Joe’s on two of the three claims, and for the plaintiffs on one of the claims. The split ruling led to both parties filing motions on November 10, 2026 seeking the other party to pay their attorney fees. In addition, both parties have already appealed the district court’s split ruling to the First Circuit Court of Appeals2.

Why Did the Plaintiffs Lose the Forfeiture Claim Before the Trial Ended?

The first result in the trial arrived before it even ended. On the penultimate day of the trial, the district court ruled against the plaintiffs on the forfeiture claims. In the court’s view, the plaintiffs’ forfeiture allegations failed to establish a breach of the duty of prudence because the plan’s committee (the Committee) allocated forfeitures in accordance with the plan document, and the plaintiffs similarly failed to establish a breach of the duty of loyalty because all of the forfeited funds remained in the plan and were allocated to participant accounts, not to Trader Joe’s.

Over the last three years, more than 100 lawsuits have been filed by plaintiff firms accusing companies of violating ERISA when they fail to use forfeited accounts in their retirement plans to reduce plan administrative expenses. Through Encore’s litigation tracking, you can count on just a few fingers the number of these lawsuits which actually allege fiduciaries did not follow their plan document’s stated use of forfeitures. The vast majority of these forfeiture lawsuits are meritless complaints – general accusations with zero reference to any flawed fiduciary process – which should be distinguished from complaints citing that employers did not follow their plan document. While many courts have seen through these general-use allegations and sided with employers, other courts have allowed these claims to advance past the motion to dismiss and, in some cases, prompted settlements.

Since May, the parties in the Trader Joe’s case have had to wait to find out how the court would rule on the plaintiffs’ other two claims, and that wait came to an end in September when the court issued a 75-page order detailing the relevant facts, the relevant law, the views of competing expert witnesses, and the court’s rulings on the plaintiffs’ remaining claims.

Why Did the Plaintiffs Lose on Investment Performance?

The court determined that Trader Joe’s did not violate ERISA by retaining the American Funds Growth Fund of America (GFA), which the plaintiffs cited as representing approximately 8% of plan assets at the beginning of the class period. Although the plaintiffs’ initial complaint challenged a series of investments that were offered in the plan’s lineup, the plaintiffs voluntarily agreed to abandon or limit the other investment allegations through a joint stipulation filed in February 2026. At trial, the plaintiffs exclusively challenged the Committee’s decision to retain the GFA, with their key focus that Trader Joe’s breached its fiduciary duties by failing to follow the plan’s investment policy statement (IPS).

According to the IPS, when reviewing existing plan investments, the Committee was required to conduct periodic evaluations and if it identified “unsatisfactory performance,” it was required to conduct a “more thorough review.” Additionally, the IPS specifically directed that, if an existing investment option is outperformed by greater than 50% of its peers over a 10-year period and its 10-year performance falls below its benchmark category, a thorough review is required.

At trial, the plaintiffs argued that Trader Joe’s breached its fiduciary duties by failing to remove the GFA once it met the aforementioned criteria. Much of the court’s order summarized the trial’s “battle of the experts” over what is and is not an appropriate peer or benchmark for purposes of interpreting the IPS.

The court’s ruling appropriately recognized that the IPS performance criteria did not require fiduciaries to automatically remove an investment that met the aforementioned criteria. Rather, the IPS only required fiduciaries to give a more thorough review to investments that met such criteria. Once the Committee identified the GFA as underperforming and placed it “on watch” in 2019, they then evaluated its performance at quarterly meetings with input from professional advisors. The court concluded that these steps were sufficient to show the Committee had engaged in a prudent monitoring process and had not acted disloyally, therefore ruling that Trader Joe’s did not violate ERISA by retaining the GFA. The court also questioned the completeness of the plaintiffs’ expert analysis, particularly its reliance on selected IPS criteria without fully evaluating investment strategy, risk-adjusted returns, qualitative factors, and the Committee’s documented review.

Why Did Trader Joe’s Lose on Recordkeeping Fees?

Although Trader Joe’s won on the first two claims, the court ruled against Trader Joe’s on the third claim focusing exclusively on the plan’s recordkeeping fees, finding the Committee’s process too passive. Despite the annual recordkeeping fee repeatedly being reduced during the class period, the court ruled in favor of the plaintiffs, stating “The Committee in this case has provided no robust evidence indicating that it engaged in a process compliant with its fiduciary duties of prudence and loyalty.” During the class period, Capital Group charged a recordkeeping fee of $48 per participant from 2019 to March 2021; $40 per participant from April 2021 to June 2024; and $38 per participant from July 2024 onward.

The approximately 20% fee reduction over the class period begs the question of how the court found Trader Joe’s violated ERISA in overseeing the recordkeeping fees. The answer, in the court’s view, was that the Committee’s process was too passive. The same ruling that found the same Committee’s process for monitoring investment performance to be sufficiently prudent found the Committee’s process for monitoring recordkeeping fees to be insufficient.

Evidently, Capital Group was retained as the plan’s recordkeeper for many years without the Committee having conducted a formal “Request for Proposal” (RFP) or less formal “Request for Information” (RFI). Instead, the Committee discussed recordkeeping fees at multiple meetings, and, upon the recommendation of its professional advisors, commissioned a benchmarking report to review where the plan’s fees stood in the market. The court indicated that the Committee relied too heavily on such benchmarking reports and did not sufficiently use the data to actually reduce plan fees.

In another instance, the plan’s advisors informally contacted two alternative recordkeepers for quotes – referred to by the court as a “soft RFP” – and each responded that it would not charge a lower per-participant fee than Capital Group. Nevertheless, the court viewed this process as insufficient. Although the Committee received information about what certain recordkeepers would charge, the Committee did not actually investigate what other recordkeepers would charge through what it referred to as “competitive market research” – i.e., a formal RFP or RFI. The Committee also did not show that fee reductions came from its own bargaining, since the reduction from $48 to $40 in 2021 apparently came from Capital Group itself and not from the Committee.

The court’s ruling is concerning since it narrowly turned on the Committee’s decision not to engage in a formal RFP or RFI. Thus, it can be interpreted that the court effectively created a formulaic fiduciary requirement that is unsupported by the text of ERISA or fiduciary norms, indicating that RFPs or RFIs are required, as are active negotiations for lower fees even after fees have already been meaningfully reduced.

Are RFPs and RFIs useful tools for supporting a prudent process?

Of course they are. Is it, however, a per se breach to use benchmarking instead of an RFP or RFI? The answer should be no. Moreover, the formulaic approach imposed by the court leaves unclear how its formula would work. How often are RFPs or RFIs needed? And what if a fiduciary determines that the cost of an RFP and the cost of any associated recordkeeper conversion would likely exceed any anticipated price concessions?

Similarly, the court’s order effectively requires fiduciaries in the same situation as Trader Joe’s to actively negotiate and seek additional price concessions. But how does a plan “negotiate” for lower fees based on benchmarking that indicates that fees are more than reasonable? And how often should such negotiation occur and how much is sufficient? Together with the court’s insistence on RFPs and RFIs, its insistence on an unclear amount of further negotiations after already receiving reduced fees creates ambiguity and potentially contradicts the broad discretion that ERISA affords to fiduciaries and the range of reasonable judgments that they may make while fulfilling their duties.

Where Did the $1.2 Million Award Come From?

The $1.2 million awarded is noteworthy and warrants discussion. The plaintiffs alleged that Trader Joe’s failed to leverage the 401(k) plan’s large asset size as bargaining power to secure lower fees, claiming that comparable large plans could have paid approximately $21 per participant for the same recordkeeping services. The plaintiffs used “expert” witness testimony presented at trial to support this claim. However, the court identified several weaknesses in this testimony, including that the benchmarking data used was insufficiently reliable for identifying what Trader Joe’s could have actually paid, and that the plaintiffs’ expert could not identify a comparable retirement plan that actually obtained similar services at $21 per participant.

Instead, the court used the $40 per-participant fee that the plan’s recordkeeper had actually offered to the plan in April 2021. The court inferred that the Committee could have secured that price at the beginning of the class period if it had followed a more prudent process, rather than waiting until the provider volunteered a reduction. Applying the $8 per-participant difference during the first two years of the class period yielded $715,264 in recordkeeping fee losses. The court then awarded $471,957 in prejudgment interest, applying Massachusetts’s 12% simple-interest rate, for a combined award of $1,187,221 – approximately $1.2 million. This was significantly lower than the $9 million that the plaintiffs sought on their recordkeeping claims.

Concluding Perspective

For years, plaintiff firms have relied on the economics of ERISA litigation to push plan sponsors and fiduciary liability insurers toward settlements rather than taking cases to trial. Given the unpredictability of trials, settlements can become attractive when discovery and defense costs exceed the settlement amount before any case can be decided on its merits.

As highlighted in our analysis of fiduciary class litigation at the beginning of the year (ERISA Fiduciary Litigation in 2025), Encore’s litigation tracking has identified more than 200 excessive fee and imprudent investment settlements over the last six years totaling more than $1.3 billion – an average of over $6 million per settlement. Yet in this case, the court awarded a significantly lower amount. That difference does not, however, mean that Trader Joe’s saved money by going to trial; it will have incurred substantial defense costs and legal expenses for experts and witnesses, plus the added risk of an appeal.

But it does show that the gap between a pleaded damages model and a proven loss can be enormous. A complaint can demand millions of dollars based on an allegedly cheaper comparator that has never been available to the defendant’s plan. At trial, however, plaintiffs must ultimately establish a defensible measure of harm to secure a realistic amount. Plan sponsors have won more trial rulings than they have lost, yet have incurred significant defense costs defending themselves. And as this trial shows, rulings don’t always go in favor of defendants, and potential damages can be costly.

Despite the unpredictable outcome for plan sponsors, the outcome for individual participants remains inevitable. When accounting for legal fees that will be taken to pay plaintiffs’ attorneys and calculating the $1.2 million damage award across the class of roughly 45,000 participants, it is expected that individual participants will each walk away with less than $20. Therefore, it appears that, even at trial, one of the few predictable elements of ERISA litigation is that expected benefits to plan participants will be minimal.

 



Justin Bove is the Chief Revenue Officer & Fiduciary Product Lead for Encore Fiduciary. He can be reached at
jbove@encorefiduciary.com.

Kent Mason and Adam McMahon are partners at Davis & Harman LLP. They can be reached at kamason@davis-harman.com and armcmahon@davis-harman.com.

Footnotes

  1. Stephan v. Trader Joe’s Company, No. 1:25-cv-10212 (D. Mass. Sept. 28, 2026).
  2. Stephan v. Trader Joe’s Company, Nos. 26-2230 and 26-2231 (1st Cir. Nov. 2, 2026).


Disclaimer: The Fid Guru Blog is intended to provide fiduciary thought leadership and advocacy for the plan sponsor community in areas of complex fiduciary litigation.  The views expressed on The Fid Guru Blog are exclusively those of the authors.  It is not affiliated with any other company and is not intended to represent the views or positions of (1) any policyholder of Encore Fiduciary, or any insurance company to which Encore Fiduciary is affiliated, or (2) any client of Davis & Harman LLP.  Quotations from this site should be credited to The Fid Guru Blog.  However, this site may not be quoted in any legal brief or any other document to be filed with any Court unless Encore Fiduciary has given its written consent in advance.  This blog does not intend to provide legal advice or recommend any specific product.  You should consult your own attorney in connection with matters affecting your legal interests.

Disclaimer:  The Fid Guru Blog is intended to provide fiduciary thought leadership and advocacy for the plan sponsor community in areas of complex fiduciary litigation.   The views expressed on The Fid Guru Blog are exclusively those of the author, and all of the content has been created solely in the author’s individual capacity.  It is not affiliated with any other company, and is not intended to represent the views or positions of any policyholder of Encore Fiduciary, or any insurance company to which Encore Fiduciary is affiliated.  Quotations from this site should credit The Fid Guru Blog.  However, this site may not be quoted in any legal brief or any other document to be filed with any Court unless the author has given his written consent in advance.  This blog does not intend to provide legal advice.  You should consult your own attorney in connection with matters affecting your legal interests.

Subscribe To

The Fid Guru Blog

Keeping you up to date on trends, emerging exposures and other critical issues.

Questions or comments
for the author?

Encore Excessive Fees Litigation cover 1.8v7

Download our Excessive Fee
White Paper

Encore Fiduciary Handbook Cover 1.8v5

Order your complimentary copy of our
Fiduciary Liability Insurance Handbook.

Topic

Talk to an Expert

An expert representative will contact you immediately.

Contact the Author

Fill out the form below to contact the author. 

Download Whitepaper

Download PDF of Handbook

Encore's Management Liability Appetite Guide

To better serve you, please share a few more details about you and your interest(s).

Encore's "MLI" Guide

To better serve you, please share a few more details about you and your interest(s).